Thesis Of Guns Germs And Steel By Jared Diamond

Thesis Of Guns Germs And Steel By Jared Diamond-35
A pertinent point raised by Roy Rosenzweig[6] and John Randolph[7] was that of the problem of incomplete knowledge, and the limitations this posed when trying to investigate the past.

A pertinent point raised by Roy Rosenzweig[6] and John Randolph[7] was that of the problem of incomplete knowledge, and the limitations this posed when trying to investigate the past.

Tags: Essay On It TechnologyRevision Essay WritingThematic Analysis DissertationHamlet Tragic Hero EssayLiterature Review On The Use Of Ict In EducationWarwick Business School Mba Essays

Although Diamond does leave some space for “human inventiveness”, as he argues that “all human societies contain inventive people”, he then goes on to state that “it’s just that some environments provide more starting materials, and more favorable conditions for utilizing inventions, than do other environments.”[11] This leads me to a second critique.

Throughout the book, Diamond fails to answer why people chose to use their technology and resources in the way that they did.

Ecological collapse is not inevitable, and the sooner we make better decisions about our resource base, the better for us.(An afterthought: one could argue that Jared Diamond’s the World Before Yesterday could be included in this collection.

In this instance, I didn’t want to include that, because Diamond’s job in Yesterday to me, was about reviewing particular societies in terms of their social dynamics — how they deal with conflict, personal risk, and with the elderly — things that are important but were on the societal side.

His piece ties in strongly with many of the works and themes we have been discussing in class, which I will attempt to address in the course of the review.

“Guns, Germs, and Steel” begins with a research question, termed “Yali’s Question”[2].

And others after him have actually taken similar approaches.

Ian Morris also took a geographically based approach.

That Eurasia is very wide means that the same plants could be planted across a huge expanse, since it is easier for crops to spread horizontally in the same latitudes then to spread across different latitudes from North to South.

That means wheat could be planted from Northern China to the Middle East — a huge geographical expanse.

SHOW COMMENTS

Comments Thesis Of Guns Germs And Steel By Jared Diamond

The Latest from srk-msk.ru ©