Conversely someone who only provides funding for the paper does not deserve to be listed as an author.Criteria to attribute authorship vary among institutions and research groups or sometimes authorship may be attributed without following any criteria at all.
We specifically speculated that addresses at Hotmail, Yahoo, Gmail, and their foreign equivalents could be indicative of a fraudulent manuscript.
However, we found that the use of non-institutional email addresses is too widespread to make it a useful criterion.
As was true of the entire Committee, the study operated independently of the ’s editorial process; the editorial process for manuscripts that were examined was not affected by the pilot study.
Following extensive deliberation, we came up with a list of criteria to screen in the pilot: As an aside – we hope that by identifying some of these criteria, we do not inspire paper mills to start changing their tactics to avoid detection by, for example, writing cover letters.
We concluded that non-institutional email addresses are present in many legitimate manuscripts and institutional email addresses are present in at least some suspected fraudulent manuscripts.
We were also aware that certain criteria (2-5) would be common for early career scientists or trainees.Hvistendahl described a situation where people were selling authorship on manuscripts that were intended to be published in journals listed in Thomson Reuters’ Scientific Citation Index (SCI).The author explains that Chinese students and faculty felt under so much pressure to publish in a SCI journal that a black market arose for “papers-for-sale.” Apparently, agencies in China work with authors of manuscripts that are conditionally accepted (in revision) at SCI journals and academics in need of authorship on such publications.Therefore he or she often receives most of the credit for the published paper but also has primary responsibility if troubles arise.In a large author team, the last author may be the most experienced researcher of the team and the one who guides the research.Usually, the author who is listed first or last will serve as the corresponding author.An “honorary author” refers to someone who is listed as an author for convenience but who does not meet formal authorship criteria.We offer these ideas up to the community, as they appear not to produce false positives and may correctly detect at least some true positives. The productivity and prestige of a research team might be established through their publication rate.Traditionally, “being in the middle” is a less desirable position, as the contribution of co-authors listed in the middle may be considered lesser.The corresponding author communicates with the journal during the publication process and is contacted for further notifications.
Comments Determining Authorship On Scientific Papers
Authorship Policy Research at Brown Brown University
Jan 24, 2018. Guidelines on Authorship in Scholarly or Scientific Publications. Determining authorship is an important component of upholding the integrity.…
Signs a scientific paper's authorship was bought – Retraction.
Oct 24, 2016. Did you know there is a black market for scientific papers. to run a pilot study to determine if we could identify papers where authorship may.…
Determining authorship for a peer-reviewed scientific publication
Aug 31, 2012. Determining authorship for a peer-reviewed scientific publication. Being an author on a paper is critically important for success in academia.…
The Art of Scientific Authorship Political Science - Bitesize Bio
Scientific authorship isn't a gift—it must be earned. Butwhat how do you determine who should share in that sunshine. widely used and trusted are those established the by International Committee of Medical Journal Editors ICMJE.…
Authorship guidelines - Harvard Medical School
Authorship is important to the reputation, academic promotion, and grant support of. Many institutions, including medical schools and peer-reviewed journals. of determining order of authorship exist across disciplines, research groups, and.…
How to handle authorship disputes - Committee on.
And take responsibility, for the research. Although journal editors do not always agree among themselves on what constitutes authorship, many of them.…
The Ethics of Authorship in Science ASCB
Aug 5, 2016. Scientific publications are the main conduit for scientists to substantiate their academic performance, and they are used in determining rewards.…
Authorship - Best Practices in Science
Unethical practices in authorship of scientific papers. Emergency Medicine, 153. Determination of authorship credit in published dissertations. Psychological.…
What Are the Factors Determining Authorship and the Order of.
Although criteria justifying authorship of scientific medical articles have been. Journal of Medicine, and to determine whether the criteria for authorship of the.…
Authorship in scientific publication - Students 4 Best Evidence
May 5, 2017. Publication is so important in science that it is referred as the “academic. The authors of a paper depend, in the end, on the agreements within.…